What Are Indirect Competitors?
Indirect competitors are businesses, products, or services that solve the same customer problem in a different way. They may not offer the same product or belong to the same category, but customers can still choose them instead of your business.
For example, a meal delivery service may compete directly with other delivery services. However, it may also compete indirectly with grocery stores, meal kits, restaurants, and customers who cook at home. Each option addresses the same underlying need: helping people get a meal with less effort.
Studying indirect competitors gives you a broader view of the market. It helps you understand what customers are really trying to accomplish, which alternatives they consider, and why they choose one option over another.
Start With the Customer Problem
The first step is to describe the customer problem without mentioning your product.
A product-focused description might be:
> Customers need project management software.
A problem-focused description could be:
> Customers need a simple way to organize work, assign responsibilities, and track progress.
The second description is more useful because it includes solutions that may not be software products. Customers might use spreadsheets, email, messaging apps, notebooks, meetings, or a full-service assistant to manage the same work.
Ask yourself:
– What task is the customer trying to complete?
– What result do they want?
– What frustration are they trying to avoid?
– What would they do if our product did not exist?
– What are they using today?
– What prevents them from changing their current approach?
The clearer your problem statement, the easier it becomes to find indirect competitors.
Define the Job Customers Need to Get Done
A helpful way to identify indirect competition is to describe the customer’s “job to be done.” This is the practical, emotional, or social outcome the customer wants.
For instance, a customer may not be buying an online course simply to watch lessons. They may be trying to:
– Learn a skill quickly
– Qualify for a new opportunity
– Build confidence
– Avoid expensive mistakes
– Create a portfolio
– Reach a personal goal
Other solutions may satisfy those same goals. These could include books, coaching, free videos, workshops, practice groups, or learning through work.
Write down the main job your product supports, then list every method customers could use to complete it. This list is often the first map of your indirect competitors.
Search for Alternatives, Not Just Competitors
Traditional competitor research usually focuses on companies with similar products. Indirect competitor research requires broader searches.
Use search phrases related to the customer’s goal, problem, and alternatives. Examples include:
– Best ways to solve [problem]
– Alternatives to [product category]
– How to [desired result]
– Tools for [customer task]
– [Product category] versus [alternative]
– How do people manage [task] without software?
– Affordable ways to [desired result]
Look at the types of results that appear. You may find product pages, comparison articles, discussion forums, tutorials, service providers, templates, and community recommendations.
Pay attention to repeated suggestions. If customers frequently mention a spreadsheet, a manual process, or a different type of service, that option may be an important indirect competitor.
Study Customer Conversations
Customers often describe their alternatives in their own words. These conversations can reveal competitors that do not appear in standard industry lists.
Useful sources include:
– Product reviews
– Community forums
– Question-and-answer websites
– Social media discussions
– Blog comments
– Customer interviews
– Support tickets
– Sales call notes
– Product comparison pages
Look for phrases such as:
– “Before using this, I relied on…”
– “Instead of buying this, I…”
– “I am deciding between…”
– “The cheaper option is…”
– “I tried doing this manually…”
– “I use a combination of…”
These statements show how customers compare solutions in real situations. They also reveal the reasons behind their choices, such as price, speed, convenience, control, trust, or familiarity.
Check Reviews for Switching Clues
Reviews are especially useful because they explain why people chose one solution over another. Read both positive and negative reviews.
In positive reviews, look for:
– Problems the customer wanted to solve
– Features that made the solution attractive
– Previous tools or methods they replaced
– Outcomes they valued most
In negative reviews, look for:
– Needs the product did not meet
– Reasons customers returned to an older method
– Complaints about complexity or cost
– Missing features that other alternatives provide
For example, a customer may praise a service for saving time but complain that it removes control. This suggests that another group of customers may prefer a slower, more customizable alternative.
Organize these observations in a simple table with columns for the alternative, customer goal, main benefit, weakness, and reason for choosing it.
Explore Adjacent Categories
Indirect competitors often come from nearby categories rather than obvious ones. To find them, consider how customers might solve the problem with a different type of purchase.
A business that sells productivity software might compete with:
– Consulting services
– Virtual assistants
– Training programs
– Templates
– Hardware tools
– Internal processes
– Free online resources
A business that sells fitness equipment might compete with:
– Gyms
– Outdoor activities
– Personal trainers
– Fitness classes
– Mobile applications
– Home exercises without equipment
Create a list of adjacent categories and ask whether each one helps customers achieve the same result. If it does, include it in your research even if the product or business model is completely different.
Identify the “Do Nothing” Competitor
One of the most important indirect competitors is inaction. Customers may decide not to purchase anything and continue with their current problem.
This can happen because:
– The problem does not feel urgent
– The customer is comfortable with an imperfect process
– Change seems difficult
– The budget is limited
– The customer does not understand the value of a new solution
– The current workaround is good enough
Treat the existing habit as a competitor. Your product must often compete not only against other businesses but also against the effort required to change.
Ask what customers currently do, how much time it takes, and what they tolerate about that process. These answers can help you explain why switching is worthwhile.
Map Competitors by Customer Need
Once you have a list of alternatives, organize them by the needs they serve. Avoid ranking them only by company size or revenue.
You can compare alternatives using factors such as:
– Price
– Speed
– Convenience
– Control
– Personalization
– Quality
– Ease of use
– Trust
– Flexibility
– Support
– Learning effort
A simple comparison table can show where each alternative performs well and where it falls short.
For example:
| Alternative | Main strength | Main weakness |
|—|—|—|
| Manual process | Low cost and high control | Takes more time |
| Specialized software | Efficient and scalable | Requires learning |
| Service provider | Saves customer effort | Costs more |
| Free resource | Easy to access | May lack support |
This process helps you see open opportunities. You may discover that customers want the convenience of software with the control of a manual process.
Validate Your Findings
A competitor list is only useful if it reflects real customer behavior. Validate your assumptions before changing your strategy.
You can ask current or potential customers:
– What do you use today to solve this problem?
– What other options did you consider?
– Why did you choose your current approach?
– What do you like and dislike about it?
– What would make you change?
– What would stop you from trying something new?
Use open-ended questions rather than asking customers to confirm your theory. Their answers may reveal alternatives you had not considered.
You can also test search demand, review patterns, customer interviews, and sales conversations together. One source may be incomplete, but several sources can show a reliable pattern.
Turn Research Into Action
Indirect competitor research should lead to practical decisions. Use your findings to improve:
– Product positioning
– Website messaging
– Sales conversations
– Content topics
– Pricing explanations
– Onboarding
– Customer support
– Feature priorities
Your messaging should explain not only what your product does but also why it is a better choice than the alternatives customers already know.
For example, instead of saying “Our platform includes automated reports,” explain how it compares with the customer’s current spreadsheet process: less manual work, fewer errors, and faster access to useful information.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Avoid these common errors when researching indirect competitors:
– Focusing only on businesses with similar products
– Ignoring manual workarounds
– Treating every possible alternative as equally important
– Looking at features without studying customer goals
– Relying on a single source of information
– Assuming the largest competitor is the biggest threat
– Forgetting that inaction can be a strong alternative
– Collecting names without recording why customers choose them
The goal is not to create the longest competitor list. It is to understand the choices customers make and the trade-offs behind those choices.
Final Thoughts
Indirect competitors reveal the full range of ways customers solve a problem. By starting with the customer’s goal, studying real conversations, exploring adjacent categories, and comparing alternatives by need, you can uncover competition that traditional research misses.
This broader view can improve your positioning, product decisions, and customer communication. Most importantly, it keeps your strategy focused on the problem customers want to solve rather than the category your business happens to occupy.
