Understanding your competitors is more than comparing products, prices, or website features. Customers encounter different brands at different points in their decision-making process, and the businesses competing for attention may change from one stage to the next.
A company that competes with you during product research may not be the same company competing with you during onboarding or renewal. Mapping competitors across the customer journey helps you see where alternatives appear, what customers value at each stage, and where your business can create a stronger experience.
What Is Competitor Mapping?
Competitor mapping is the process of identifying and comparing businesses that influence a customer’s decision. The goal is not simply to create a list of similar companies. Instead, you examine how competitors appear throughout the customer journey.
This approach includes:
– Direct competitors offering a similar product or service
– Indirect competitors solving the same problem differently
– Substitute solutions, such as spreadsheets, internal processes, or do-it-yourself options
– Content creators, review sites, and marketplaces that influence customer choices
– Existing providers that compete for renewals, upgrades, or referrals
A journey-based map shows when each competitor becomes visible and how they affect customer decisions.
The Main Stages of the Customer Journey
Every business may define its journey differently, but most customer journeys include six common stages:
- Awareness
- Consideration
- Evaluation
- Purchase
- Onboarding and use
- Retention and advocacy
Mapping competitors across these stages gives your analysis a practical structure.
Stage 1: Awareness
At the awareness stage, customers recognize a problem, need, or opportunity. They may not yet know which products or services can help.
Competitors at this stage often include:
– Brands ranking in search results
– Educational websites
– Industry publications
– Social media accounts
– Podcasts, newsletters, and online communities
– Companies with strong brand recognition
These businesses may not offer the same product as you. However, they compete for the customer’s time, attention, and understanding.
What to Analyze
Review the questions customers ask when they first notice a problem. Search for those questions online and record which companies appear most often.
Look at:
– Search rankings
– Blog topics
– Videos and guides
– Social media discussions
– Lead magnets and email sign-up offers
– Brand messages and positioning
Ask whether competitors explain the problem clearly and whether their content helps customers take a useful next step.
Mapping Tip
Create a simple table with columns for the customer question, competing source, content type, and message. This reveals which competitors are shaping customer expectations before product research even begins.
Stage 2: Consideration
During consideration, customers begin exploring possible solutions. They may compare broad categories, providers, or approaches.
For example, a customer might compare software with a manual process, an agency with an in-house team, or a subscription service with a one-time purchase.
What to Analyze
Identify the options customers are likely to consider, including alternatives outside your category. Then compare how each option presents its value.
Review:
– Product pages
– Service descriptions
– Educational resources
– Customer stories
– Comparison pages
– Pricing explanations
– Frequently asked questions
Pay attention to the language competitors use. Do they focus on saving time, reducing complexity, improving quality, or offering flexibility? Their messaging can show what customers expect from the category.
Mapping Tip
Separate competitors into three groups:
– Direct competitors: Similar offerings for the same audience
– Indirect competitors: Different offerings that solve a related problem
– Substitutes: Noncommercial or internal options customers may use instead
This prevents your analysis from becoming too narrow.
Stage 3: Evaluation
At the evaluation stage, customers compare specific providers more closely. They may read reviews, request demonstrations, test products, or ask for recommendations.
This is often where competitor research becomes more detailed and measurable.
What to Analyze
Compare the actual customer experience of researching each option. Review:
– Feature descriptions
– Product demonstrations
– Free trials or samples
– Customer reviews
– Case studies
– Support documentation
– Service guarantees
– Integration information
– Accessibility of sales or support teams
Do not focus only on what competitors claim. Examine how easy it is for a customer to find answers and understand the differences between options.
Build a Comparison Scorecard
A scorecard can make evaluation more consistent. Choose criteria that matter to your customers, such as:
– Ease of use
– Range of features
– Setup requirements
– Customer support
– Customization
– Educational resources
– Transparency of pricing
– Evidence of results
Use a simple rating scale and include notes or examples for each score. The purpose is not to declare a universal winner. It is to identify areas where customers may see meaningful differences.
Stage 4: Purchase
At the purchase stage, the customer is ready to take action. Competitors may influence the final decision through pricing, contract terms, sales communication, checkout design, or perceived risk.
What to Analyze
Review the steps between initial intent and completed purchase. Compare:
– Number of steps in the buying process
– Required forms and information
– Pricing clarity
– Payment or booking options
– Sales response times
– Contract or cancellation details
– Confirmation messages
– Availability of human assistance
A complicated purchase process can create an opening for a competitor with a simpler experience. On the other hand, a highly assisted sales process may appeal to customers who need guidance before committing.
Mapping Tip
Complete the purchase journey yourself where appropriate and allowed. Record every question, delay, or point of confusion. You can also use publicly available information, customer interviews, and user testing to understand the experience without making assumptions.
Stage 5: Onboarding and Use
The customer journey continues after the sale. Onboarding shapes how quickly customers understand the product, reach their first success, and build regular usage.
Competitors at this stage may include other providers, internal experts, training resources, and tools that help customers complete the same task.
What to Analyze
Compare:
– Welcome messages
– Setup instructions
– Tutorials and checklists
– Training materials
– Account configuration
– First-use guidance
– Support channels
– Time required to reach an early result
Look for gaps between what competitors promise and what they help customers accomplish. A company may have impressive features but a confusing setup process. Another may offer fewer features but make the first experience much easier.
Stage 6: Retention and Advocacy
After customers begin using a product or service, competitors can still affect the relationship. Alternative providers may appear during renewal, expansion, or moments of dissatisfaction.
Customers may also influence others through reviews, referrals, and public feedback.
What to Analyze
Study the ongoing experience, including:
– Renewal reminders
– Account reviews
– Product updates
– Loyalty programs
– Customer education
– Support quality
– Feedback requests
– Referral programs
– Review site activity
Pay attention to why customers stay, switch, recommend, or remain inactive. Interviews, surveys, support records, and review analysis can help identify recurring patterns.
Create a Competitor Journey Map
Bring your findings together in one visual or spreadsheet. Use customer journey stages as rows and competitor categories as columns.
For each stage, record:
– Competitors present
– Customer needs
– Main decision factors
– Competitor messages
– Customer concerns
– Evidence or sources
– Your current strengths
– Gaps and opportunities
Add a date to every entry. Competitor positioning, pricing, content, and customer experiences can change over time.
Turn Findings Into Action
A competitor map is most useful when it supports practical decisions. Prioritize opportunities based on customer importance, business impact, and the effort required to improve.
Possible actions include:
– Creating content for overlooked customer questions
– Clarifying product differences
– Simplifying the buying process
– Improving onboarding materials
– Strengthening support documentation
– Updating comparison pages
– Addressing common review concerns
– Developing stronger retention or referral experiences
Avoid copying competitors directly. Use the map to understand customer expectations, then build improvements that fit your own strengths and audience.
Review the Map Regularly
Competitor mapping should be an ongoing practice rather than a one-time project. Set a regular review schedule, such as quarterly or twice a year. Update the map when you launch a product, enter a new market, change pricing, or notice shifts in customer behavior.
When competitors are mapped across the full journey, your analysis becomes more useful than a simple feature comparison. It shows where customers discover choices, what influences their decisions, and how your business can deliver a clearer, more consistent experience from first contact through long-term loyalty.
